Use the quality mode documented for your encoder, then compare identical sample passages. OBS lists CQP/Constant QP, CRF and ICQ baselines; lower quality-number values generally mean higher quality and larger files within that mode.
Choose an encoder-appropriate quality control, compare the same difficult footage, and balance recording detail against file size.
In this guide
Before you start
- A duplicate recording profile and a player or editor that opens its output.
- A repeatable scene with motion, fine detail and readable text.
Read the control that belongs to your encoder
A number copied from another creator is incomplete without the encoder and rate-control mode. A quality value used with x264 is not a universal score that can be transferred unchanged to every hardware encoder. Start by noting the encoder, codec, mode and output resolution in the profile you are testing.
The OBS advanced recording guide gives encoder-specific baselines: Constant QP/CQP for the listed NVENC and AMD examples, CRF for x264 and ICQ for Quick Sync. Its 16–23 examples are starting ranges, not a guarantee that a particular value is best for your footage or storage budget.
Choose footage that exposes the tradeoff
Build a short passage containing the hardest material you expect to keep: a moving game camera, detailed foliage, animated graphics, or small application text. Include a quiet moment too. A static title card alone is unlikely to reveal what happens during the demanding part of the session.
Keep resolution, frame rate, scene content and playback size fixed while comparing quality values. If you change the encoder and the scene at the same time, a larger file may have several explanations. Give each sample a label linked to a simple settings note rather than relying on memory.
Make a small quality ladder
Establish the first sample
Choose the mode that matches your encoder and an appropriate documented starting value. Record the repeatable passage and keep the file as your baseline.
Look for: The first file has a known encoder, quality setting and duration.
Change one quality value
Within the same encoder and mode, make a modest quality-value change and repeat the passage. OBS documents lower values as higher-quality, larger-file settings for its listed modes.
Look for: You have a second comparable file rather than two unrelated recordings.
Inspect detail and size together
Play both at the intended viewing size, then inspect the hardest frames and the file sizes. Note whether the improvement is visible where the footage will actually be used.
Look for: You can choose a tradeoff based on a concrete difference in the material you record.
Keep compression quality separate from encoder overload
If the sample stutters or OBS reports an encoding problem, resolve that before judging small differences in image quality. A cleaner individual frame is not useful if the sequence is unreliable. Watch the output under the same application workload you will use for the real recording.
Estimate storage from the representative sample and leave room for variation and longer takes. Avoid treating the short test as an exact hourly guarantee. Keep the original capture quality sufficient for the intended edit; an unnecessarily huge file can make storage and handoff harder without a visible benefit.
Save the decision with its intended use
Write why you kept the final value: small text stayed readable, motion artifacts were acceptable, or the quality improvement did not justify the extra space. That explanation is more useful when revisiting the settings than a label such as best quality.
Repeat the comparison after a meaningful encoder, codec or content change. For a simple workflow, OBS recommends Simple output mode as the easier starting point; use Advanced when you need the extra control. A manageable setting you understand is easier to maintain than a copied preset whose tradeoffs remain unknown.
Still stuck?
The higher-quality sample stutters.
Check encoding and rendering performance under the real workload before comparing image detail or choosing a larger file.
Sources & references
Based on the linked first-party OBS documentation checked on 4 November 2026. The exercises and acceptance checks are editorial workflows for you to run; no hands-on OBS session or hardware benchmark is claimed.
- OBS — Advanced Recording Settings Guide ↗Checked 2026-11-04
- OBS — Encoding Performance Troubleshooting ↗Checked 2026-11-04
Spotted something out of date? Let Alex know.
How we put our guides together ↗