Practical hardware guide

4K Pro: monitor works but high-refresh capture is black

Test Display Stream Compression and source-format compatibility when a high-refresh monitor works but 4K Pro capture remains black.

START HERE

Elgato documents DSC as a possible cause when the play display works but captured video is black. Test a lower supported source resolution or refresh rate, then verify the card's current firmware and driver format support.

A known working capture mode and evidence showing whether the failure follows a high-bandwidth source format.

In this guide
Before you start
  • A 4K Pro with a working direct source-to-display connection.
  • The exact monitor, GPU, driver and capture firmware versions.

Before you change the setup

High-refresh displays can use Display Stream Compression to carry a signal. A capture path must explicitly support the actual signal format; an HDMI 2.1 label by itself is not a promise that every monitor mode can be recorded. Elgato identifies DSC as a limitation to investigate when passthrough appears normal but capture is black.

The useful experiment changes the signal leaving the source. Reducing the recording canvas or scaling the OBS preview does not change what arrives at HDMI IN. Keep those downstream settings steady while you compare source modes. This avoids attributing a successful fallback to the wrong part of the chain.

Run a controlled check

  1. Record the failing configuration

    Write down the source resolution and refresh rate, HDR state, monitor model and port, capture driver and firmware. Check the monitor manual for DSC or high-refresh restrictions instead of assuming all 4K modes behave alike.

    Look for: The failing combination is specific enough to compare with supported-format documentation.

  2. Establish a conservative source mode

    Choose a lower resolution or refresh rate that the source, display and capture device all support. Use a simple SDR mode for the first comparison if several variables were enabled, documenting that this is a baseline.

    Look for: A successful baseline proves the main capture path can produce an image without claiming the original high-refresh mode is supported.

  3. Raise one requirement at a time

    Increase refresh rate while holding resolution steady, or increase resolution while holding refresh steady. Record a short clip after each change. Restore the last working mode if the preview disappears.

    Look for: You identify the transition that breaks capture instead of collecting unrelated successful settings.

  4. Check version-specific support

    Compare the installed driver/firmware with the current 4K Pro resolution documentation. That page includes additional modes tied to a specific software/driver channel; do not assume a mode advertised there is active on every installation.

    Look for: The expected capture format matches the software actually installed, including any documented release-channel limitation.

  5. Keep a verified operating profile

    Save the source settings that survive a restart and produce a playable recording. If the monitor exposes a documented DSC control, compare it only as directed by its own manual, then repeat the same capture test.

    Look for: You finish with a repeatable operating choice and a clear record of its refresh-rate tradeoff.

Read the result and keep a working setup

A lower mode working is evidence of a signal-format boundary, but it does not alone prove DSC. Cable bandwidth, monitor timing and capture software support can produce similar symptoms. Use the monitor's documentation or diagnostics to confirm DSC rather than declaring the capture card defective or the compression definitely active.

Manufacturer documentation can contain a longstanding specification table alongside newer firmware notes. Record which section and version your setup follows, especially before switching to a beta driver. An experimental update is optional; a stable lower mode may be the better choice for an upcoming broadcast. Keep the previous working configuration available until the new one has survived a full rehearsal.

Keep these distinctions clear

Keep these distinctions clear
ChangeDoes it test the HDMI input format?
Lower the source refresh rateYes.
Resize the OBS canvasNo; it changes downstream composition.
Use another supported monitor timingYes, when changed at the source.

Try it on your own setup

Start small: try the free files or continue with a guide for the part you’re working on.

4K Passthrough or 4K Recording? Read the Capture Card Spec ↗

Sources & references

Documentation review checked 4 November 2026 using the primary sources listed below. This is not a hands-on product test: the diagnostic sequence and rehearsal suggestions are Foxdip editorial guidance. No measured performance, search volume, price or universal compatibility result is claimed.

  1. Elgato Game Capture 4K Pro — Supported Resolutions and Frame Rates ↗Checked 2026-11-04
  2. Elgato Game Capture 4K Pro — Technical Specifications ↗Checked 2026-11-04

Spotted something out of date? Let Alex know.

How we put our guides together ↗
READ NEXT

A few places to go from here.

All stories

4K Passthrough or 4K Recording? Read the Capture Card Spec

Separate the HDMI display path from the USB recording path, then read resolution, frame rate, HDR and host bandwidth as one supported combination.

HD60 X Passthrough Looks Right but the Recording Colours Do Not

Separate HDR tone mapping from an HDMI range mismatch before adding colour filters to HD60 X footage.