Compare the original and export in the same viewing conditions before changing the artwork. A color profile gives RGB values their intended meaning; a missing or mismatched profile can complicate comparisons. For a web delivery copy, use a documented conversion to sRGB when appropriate, while preserving the original master.
A documented export path that separates profile conversion from intentional recoloring and from differences between displays.
In this guide
Before you start
- The original file with its known profile if available.
- GIMP 3 or another color-managed editor.
- A repeatable comparison on the same display, with the same background.
Start with the actual job
A brighter image on a phone is not automatically evidence that the PNG export is wrong. Different displays, brightness settings and viewing applications can change the experience. Begin with one machine and one viewing context so the investigation does not mix several variables at once.
Avoid solving a color-management problem by repeatedly adjusting saturation until one preview looks right. That can make the master inconsistent and create a new problem elsewhere. Keep the source, a converted copy and the exported delivery file distinguishable by filename.
Work through the setup
Establish a controlled comparison
Open the master and delivery file on the same display against the same background. Note whether the difference affects all colors or only a particular edge or transparent region.
Look for: The comparison is repeatable and does not depend on memory from another screen.
Inspect the known source profile
Review the document’s color profile. If the source has no reliable profile information, consult the creator or original export settings rather than assigning one at random.
Look for: You know whether a meaningful conversion can be made from the current source.
Convert a delivery copy
In GIMP, use Image, Color Management, Convert to Color Profile and choose the intended sRGB destination. Keep the original master unchanged and review the conversion preview.
Look for: The copy is deliberately converted instead of merely relabeled with a different interpretation.
Export and reopen
Export the delivery image, reopen it and compare again in the same conditions. Record the destination profile and any relevant export options.
Look for: A later revision can repeat the same process rather than recreating it by eye.
Compare the decisions
| Situation or element | Decision | Check |
|---|---|---|
| Different only on another display | Control the viewing conditions | Do not immediately recolor |
| Different after profile conversion | Inspect conversion and gamut choices | Preserve the master |
| Only transparent edges differ | Check alpha and matte color | Treat edge blending separately |
| Unknown source profile | Recover reliable source information | Avoid arbitrary assignment |
Review the result and keep the master
For an identity kit, keep a small reference sheet with the intended color values and the delivery color space. Values alone are not the whole appearance, but the sheet makes accidental palette changes easier to detect. Include neutral grays and the main accent rather than hundreds of swatches.
Do not promise identical appearance on every device. The practical goal is a consistent, documented file and a sensible comparison method. If only a particular application shows the discrepancy, investigate that application’s handling before modifying all graphics in the set.
Still stuck?
Assigning sRGB made the colors worse
Return to the preserved source and distinguish profile assignment from conversion.
Every screen looks slightly different
Compare on one controlled display first and avoid chasing each device with separate artwork edits.
Only a glow changes over dark content
Inspect its alpha and edge colors; the problem may be compositing rather than the overall profile.
Want graphics that already fit? Browse ready-to-upload emote packs ↗
Sources & references
Primary-documentation review checked on 4 November 2026, with original practical editing and review steps. Platform requirements are sourced; design choices are editorial recommendations. No hands-on upload, account access, screenshot capture or comparative performance test is claimed.
- Photopea — Color Spaces ↗Checked 2026-11-04
- GIMP 3 — Convert to Color Profile ↗Checked 2026-11-04
Spotted something out of date? Let Alex know.
How we put our guides together ↗